Medical Devices Home      Exposition      To Register      ASM Homepage
Back to "Effect of Materials on Treatment & Surgical Techniques - Session 3" Search
    Back to Main Search

Tuesday, August 11, 2009 - 4:00 PM
14.2

Cellular Response and Degradation Products In Failed Metal-On-Metal Disc Replacements

R. M. Urban, M. A. Wimmer, J. J. Jacobs, Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL; N. J. Hallab, Rush University Medical School, Chicago, IL

Introduction: Metal-on-metal bearings for disc replacement have been introduced as an alternative to polyethylene bearings to reduce the generation of wear particles. These disc replacements utilize CoCrMo alloys but otherwise differ from metal-on-metal hip replacement bearings in geometry, size and kinematics. There is a paucity of data on the histology and degradation products generated in vivo by disc replacement devices.

Methods: Periprosthetic tissues were studied from 5 cases of metal-on-metal lumbar or cervical disc replacement revised for pseudo-tumor formation. Histological sections stained with hematoxylin and eosin and in selected cases with immunohistochemical reagents were studied using light microscopy. Unstained sections were analyzed using backscattered electron imaging and energy-dispersive x-ray analysis.

Results: The masses adjacent to disc replacements revealed large areas with coagulation necrosis of fibro-connective and adipose tissue. Peripheral areas of viable tissue demonstrated fibrosis and chronic inflammation. The cellular infiltrate was dominated by lymphocytes and included a moderate number of macrophages, focal accumulations of degranulating eosinophils and, in one case, numerous plasma cells. Submicron metallic particles similar in composition to wear particles generated by metal-on-metal hip bearings were identified in 3 of the 5 spinal masses. The particles were rich in chromium, oxygen and phosphorous and deficient in cobalt relative to the base alloy. Particles in which cobalt is deficient or absent suggests substantial local metal ion release.

Discussion: The histopathology of pseudo-tumors associated with cervical and lumbar disc replacement was similar to reactions previously characterized as metal hypersensitivity in patients hosting metal-on-metal hip replacement, except for the large number of eosinophils observed in several cases of disc replacement. Degranulating eosinophils may be related to a local allergic reaction in these patients. The prevalence of lymphocyte dominated reactions in patients with metal-on-metal bearings is thought to be <3% in hip replacement and presently is unknown in disc replacement.


Summary: Metal-on-metal bearings for disc replacement have been introduced to reduce wear and the adverse tissue response to polyethylene particles. Although these devices have been studied extensively in vitro, there is a paucity of data on the histology and actual degradation products generated in vivo. Periprosthetic tissues were studied from 5 cases of metal-on-metal lumbar or cervical disc replacement revised for pseudo-tumor formation. The cellular response and wear debris in tissues surrounding failed spinal disc replacements was similar to reactions reported in association with revised metal-on-metal hip replacement in that the tissues demonstrated widespread necrosis and chronic inflammation dominated by lymphocytes. Several cases also showed numerous degranulating eosinophils. Submicron metallic particles in which cobalt was deficient or absent suggested substantial local metal ion release. The majority of patients hosting metal-on-metal disc replacement have had a favorable outcome. However, a subset of patients may exhibit an adverse response to wear and corrosion products.