Shape Memory Home      Exposition      To Register      ASM Homepage
Back to "Medical Applications, Design and Implementation - POSTER" Search
    Back to Main Search

Monday, May 17, 2010

Evaluation of the Mechanical Properties of 34 NiTi Archwires in a Three-Point Bending Test and DSC

L. M. Brauchli, University Basel, Basel, Switzerland; A. Wichelhaus, University München, München, Germany

Introduction: In modern orthodontic treatment NiTi archwires are widely used for initial alignement of the teeth. Whereas with stainless steel archwires the main factor affecting stiffness is the wire geometry, NiTi archwires are much more dependent on the properties of the alloy. Thus the force delivery of NiTi archwires cannot be easily calculated. It is the aim of this study to give an overview of force levels and superelastic behavior of different NiTi archwires.

Material and Methods: 34 NiTi archwires from five different manufacturers (Dentaurum, Forestadent, Ormco, Ortho Organizers, 3M/Unitek) were evaluated for their mechanical properties in a three point bending test according to ISO norms on an Instron 4444. 6 archwires each were tested at 37°C. Deactivation curves were evaluated for the characteristic force level at 1.5mm deflection and the force variance over the plateau region. DSC was evaluated for Af temperatures.

Results: Overall mean forces ranged from 0.48N (Copper NiTi 40°C, .016x.022”) to 6.9N (Nitinol Classic, .018x.025”) with ratios of variance ranging from 0.4 (Copper NiTi 40°C, .016x.022”) to 6.7 (Titanol Superelastic, .016”) and Af temperatures from 10.9°C to 60.1°C. Three point bending yielded reliable results with very low standard deviations. Out of a total of 560 comparisons 80 (xy%) were not significant. 24 of the non-significant comparisons were found in between archwires of the dimension .016” to large rectangular archwires (.017x.025” - .019x.025”). Conclusion: The proposed evaluation method for NiTi archwires turned out to be a useful routine. The forces of the NiTi archwires ranged from 0.5 to 7N and cross-sectional dimension had a minor influence on force levels than in stainless steel wires. DSC measurements roughly correlated with the force levels.


Summary: In modern orthodontic treatment NiTi archwires are widely used for initial tooth alignement. As the force delivery of NiTi archwires cannot be easily calculated, it is the aim of this study to give an overview of force levels and Af temperatures of different Nickel-Titanium archwires. In addition a "ratio of variance" was defined, which allowed for a clinically usefull characterization of the superelastic qualities of the products tested.